American Nations by Colin Woodard

 Nationhood Lab – An initiative of the Pell Center at Salve Regina University

American Nations


My cousin Lynn recommended this book.  It takes a look at the different religious and political nature of each of the colonies and how they moved west.


Introduction to (American) Nations and Faith

This project began in 2023 with two interests that I've carried for many years: a fascination with American culture and politics, and a fascination with religion.

The name comes in part from the book American Nations by Colin Woodard, which explores the idea that the United States is not one culture, but many regional cultures with different values, histories, political traditions, and ways of seeing the world.

Over time, I became interested in another question:

Why do Americans practice Christianity so differently from one another?

Why do some churches emphasize social justice, inclusion, and questioning?

Why do others emphasize authority, certainty, tradition, or personal salvation?

Why do people who all call themselves Christian sometimes seem to have completely different beliefs about God, politics, morality, and society?

Those questions eventually became this project.

But there is another reason I wanted to create this blog.

As a therapist, I have worked with many people whose religious experiences have been deeply painful. Some grew up in highly controlling, legalistic, authoritarian, or spiritually abusive environments. Others experienced shame, rejection, fear, or exclusion because of who they were or what they believed.

The Psychological Effects of High-Control Religious Environments

Leaving the Fold

Many of these individuals reached a difficult conclusion:

"If this is Christianity, then Christianity is not for me."

For some people, that conclusion is correct and authentic. They may ultimately choose another faith tradition, spirituality outside organized religion, or no religion at all.

But for others, I sometimes notice something different.

They don't realize that the church they grew up in represents only one small corner of a vast Christian landscape.

A person may leave a highly conservative church without realizing there are moderate churches.

They may leave a moderate church without realizing there are progressive churches.

They may never discover traditions that approach scripture, authority, gender roles, social issues, doubt, science, or spirituality very differently.

In my own life, I became interested in these differences largely by accident.

While living in The Dalles and later Hood River, I spent years attending churches of many different denominations and traditions. Some of that came through relationships I formed in recovery communities. Some of it was simple curiosity.

Over time, I probably visited around twenty churches.

I attended not because I was looking for the "right" church, but because I was trying to understand people.

It became something of a sociology experiment.

I discovered that "Christianity" is not one thing.

There are enormous differences between denominations, congregations, regions, and cultures.

Christian Denominations: Liberal to Conservative

A progressive Episcopal church may feel worlds apart from a fundamentalist independent Bible church.

A mainline Lutheran congregation may have very different priorities from a Pentecostal church.


Two churches in the same town may share the same Bible while communicating completely different experiences of faith.

Eventually I developed a habit of helping people explore those differences. One resource I often share is a Christian denomination selector, simply because many people don't realize how many options exist.

Key Christian Beliefs

 Christian Denomination Selector Instant Match Religion Yes/No Selector Quiz

Today, I am no longer a Christian myself. My own journey led me in a different direction, and I remain somewhat ambivalent about faith and religion.

But I also believe that no single movement should get to define Christianity for everyone else.

In particular, I don't believe Christian nationalism, fundamentalism, or authoritarian religious movements should be allowed to speak as if they represent all Christians.

Millions of Christians disagree with those perspectives.

Millions of Christians practice their faith in ways that are compassionate, thoughtful, inclusive, and intellectually curious.

The goal of this blog is not to tell people what to believe.

It is not to convince people to become religious.

And it is not to convince people to leave religion.

Instead, my hope is to provide historical context, cultural context, and a framework for understanding the incredible diversity that exists within American religion.

We'll explore denominations, regional cultures, political patterns, religious history, theological differences, church traditions, and the ways that faith intersects with identity and community.

Most importantly, I hope this blog helps people recognize that they have choices.

Whether you remain in your tradition, find a different tradition, leave religion entirely, or continue searching, I want people to know that they are allowed to ask questions.

They are allowed to grow.

They are allowed to change.

And they are allowed to build a spiritual life that reflects their deepest values rather than their deepest fears.

Thank you for joining me on the journey.

Welcome to Nations and Faith.


"Religion in Colonial America was dominated by Christianity although Judaism was practiced in small communities after 1654. Christian denominations included Anglicans, Baptists, Catholics, Congregationalists, German Pietists, Lutherans, Methodists, and Quakers among others. Religion was fully integrated into the lives of the colonists and completely informed their world view. The New England Colonies had been founded by separatists – Anglicans who advocated separation from the Anglican Church – and Puritans – those who sought to purify Anglicanism of Catholic influences and practices – while the Middle and Southern Colonies were founded by Anglicans, Quakers, or in the case of Maryland, Catholics and non-conformist Protestants." source

Introduction

PART ONE

Origins: 1590 to 1769

Chapter 1: Founding El Norte

Chapter 2: Founding New France

Chapter 3: Founding Tidewater Virginia colony "Tidewater"

Chapter 4: Founding Yankeedom Massachusetts Bay

(Portland was founded by yankees)

Chapter 5: Founding New Netherland

Maryland colony, 

Connecticut colony, 

New Jersey colony, 

New York, 

Rhode Island colony , 

New Hampshire, 

Pennsylvania

Chapter 6: The Colonies’ First Revolt

Chapter 7: Founding the Deep South North Carolina colony, South Carolina colony, Georgia colony

Chapter 8: Founding the Midlands Midlands


Midlands

 

Chapter 9: Founding Greater Appalachia Greater Appalachia

PART TWO

Unlikely Allies: 1770 to 1815

Chapter 10: A Common Struggle

Chapter 11: Six Wars of Liberation

Chapter 12: Independence or Revolution?

Chapter 13: Nations in the North

Chapter 14: First Secessionists

PART THREE

Wars for the West: 1816 to 1877

Chapter 15: Yankeedom Spreads West

Chapter 16: The Midlands Spread West

Chapter 17: Appalachia Spreads West

Chapter 18: The Deep South Spreads West

Chapter 19: Conquering El Norte

Chapter 20: Founding the Left Coast The Left Coast

Chapter 21: War for the West

PART FOUR

Culture Wars: 1878 to 2010

Chapter 22: Founding the Far West

Chapter 23: Immigration and Identity

Chapter 24: Gods and Missions

Chapter 25: Culture Clash

Chapter 26: War, Empire, and the Military

Chapter 27: The Struggle for Power I: The Blue Nations

Chapter 28: The Struggle for Power II: The Red and the Purple


American Nations: A History of the Eleven Rival Regional Cultures of North America by Colin Woodard.

The Thirteen Colonies in their traditional groupings were: the New England Colonies (Province of New Hampshire, Province of Massachusetts Bay, Colony of Rhode Island and Providence Plantations, and Connecticut Colony); the Middle Colonies (Province of New York, Province of New Jersey, Province of Pennsylvania, and Delaware Colony); and the Southern Colonies (Province of Maryland, Colony of Virginia, Province of North Carolina, Province of South Carolina, and Province of Georgia).[2] These colonies were part of British America, which also included territory in the Floridas, the Caribbean, and what is today Canada.[3]




This blog explores the history, culture, and beliefs that have shaped the American Nations. While I have a personal interest in religion and religious history, I am not affiliated with any religious organization, denomination, or faith tradition. My goal is to understand and discuss these topics from a historical, cultural, and sociological perspective rather than to promote any particular set of beliefs.  Jane Rekas, LCSW

Comments

intro

Popular Posts