Classic Liberal











Jeremiah Wright, Marcus Borg, John Dominic Crossan, Shelby Spong, The Christian Left, United Church of Christ, Unitarian, Union Seminary

Jeremiah Alvesta Wright Jr. (born September 22, 1941) is a pastor emeritus of Trinity United Church of Christ in Chicago, a congregation he led for 36 years, during which its membership grew to over 8,000 parishioners.

Marcus Joel Borg (March 11, 1942 – January 21, 2015) was an American New Testament scholar and theologian. He was among the most widely known and influential voices in Liberal Christianity.

John Dominic Crossan (born 17 February 1934) is an Irish-American New Testament scholar, historian of early Christianity, former Catholic priest who was a prominent member of the Jesus Seminar, and emeritus professor at DePaul University.

John Shelby "Jack" Spong (June 16, 1931 – September 12, 2021) was an American bishop of the Episcopal Church. From 1979 to 2000, he was the Bishop of Newark, New Jersey.

The Christian left is a range of Christian political and social movements that largely embrace social justice principles and uphold a social doctrine or social gospel.



Union Theological Seminary in the City of New York (UTS) is a private ecumenical Christian liberal seminary in Morningside Heights, Manhattan, affiliated with neighboring Columbia University.

Liberal

Liberal or mainline American Christianity, these names fit together surprisingly well, but they represent several distinct strands: liberal theology, historical-critical biblical scholarship, Black liberation theology, progressive Christianity, and the Christian social-justice tradition. They should not all be collapsed into “the Christian Left.”

A useful family tree is:

19th-century theological liberalism + Social Gospel + historical biblical criticism
↓
Mainline Protestant liberalism
↓
Civil Rights / Black theology / liberation theology / feminist theology
↓
Progressive Christianity and the contemporary Christian Left

Here is where each of your names fits.


1. Marcus Borg: liberal Christianity made spiritually accessible

Marcus Borg (1942–2015) was an American New Testament scholar, historical-Jesus scholar, and one of the best-known popularizers of liberal/progressive Christianity. Raised Lutheran, he studied at Union Theological Seminary and Oxford and spent 28 years teaching at Oregon State University. Later he was Canon Theologian at Trinity Episcopal Cathedral in Portland. [en.wikipedia.org], [marcusjborg.org], [episcopaln...ervice.org]

Borg is particularly important because he tried to answer something like:

Can I stop believing literally in much of traditional Christian doctrine and still be deeply Christian?

His answer was emphatically yes.

He used historical-critical scholarship to distinguish the historical Jesus from layers of interpretation developed by the early church. He was a prominent member of the Jesus Seminar, although he retained a stronger sense of spirituality and the reality of God than some of its other scholars. [marcusjborg.org], [episcopaln...ervice.org]

In simplified terms, Borg tended to see:

  • the Bible as a collection of historically conditioned human testimonies about encounters with God, rather than an inerrant divine transcript;

  • Jesus as Jewish teacher, healer, prophet, wisdom figure and social critic;

  • Christian language as frequently metaphorical and sacramental rather than literal;

  • Christianity primarily as a transformative way or path, rather than intellectual assent to a collection of supernatural propositions.

That is why Borg's books such as Meeting Jesus Again for the First Time, Reading the Bible Again for the First Time, and The Heart of Christianity became particularly attractive to people who had outgrown conservative Christianity but did not want to abandon Christianity itself. [marcusjborg.org]

Given the way you've talked with me about astrology and Human Design as potentially symbolically meaningful without having to establish literal truth claims first, I suspect you might find Borg particularly interesting. His approach to religious language has some similarities: What does this symbol disclose or evoke? becomes at least as important as Did the event literally happen exactly this way?


2. John Dominic Crossan: the historical-Jesus scholar

John Dominic Crossan (born 1934) comes from a different background. He was born in Ireland, entered the Catholic Servite order, was ordained a Roman Catholic priest in 1957, studied at the Pontifical Biblical Institute in Rome, left the priesthood in 1969, and taught religious studies at DePaul University. He became one of the leading figures of the Jesus Seminar. [en.wikipedia.org], [britannica.com], [westarinstitute.org]

Crossan is less a denominational liberal theologian and more a historian of Jesus and early Christianity.

One of his central questions is:

What can historians plausibly reconstruct about Jesus before later Christian theology developed around him?

His reconstruction emphasizes Jesus within the political, economic and social world of Roman-occupied first-century Palestine. He has particularly emphasized communal meals, healing, social equality and resistance to hierarchy and imperial domination. [en.wikipedia.org], [britannica.com]

Crossan consequently interprets a number of traditional supernatural claims metaphorically or theologically rather than straightforwardly as historical reports. That makes him much more radical historically than an ordinary mainline Protestant pastor.

Interestingly, Borg and Crossan became collaborators. They coauthored The Last Week, The First Christmas, and The First Paul. [marcusjborg.org]

So:

Borg = "How can modern people remain Christian?"
Crossan = "What was Jesus historically doing and saying?"

There is considerable overlap, but the emphasis differs.


3. John Shelby Spong: the radical Episcopal bishop

John Shelby Spong (1931–2021), commonly called Jack Spong, was an Episcopal priest and eventually Episcopal Bishop of Newark from 1979 to 2000. [en.wikipedia.org]

Spong moved considerably farther from traditional Christian doctrine than the average liberal Episcopalian.

His project was essentially:

Christianity must radically reinterpret its ancient supernatural worldview if it is going to remain intellectually credible in the modern world.

Hence his skepticism toward traditional interpretations of such beliefs as the virgin birth, bodily resurrection, miracles, biblical inerrancy and a supernatural interventionist God.

This made Spong enormously appealing to some Christians who felt forced to choose between fundamentalism and atheism.

But it also helps to distinguish two concepts:

Liberal Christianity ≠ Spong.

An ELCA Lutheran, UCC member, Methodist, Episcopalian or Presbyterian can accept evolution, historical criticism, LGBTQ inclusion, women clergy, interfaith dialogue and social justice while still affirming the Trinity, divinity of Christ and resurrection.

Spong represents a particularly radical wing of theological liberalism, not the doctrinal position of the Episcopal Church as a whole. His own ecclesiastical home remained the Episcopal Church. [en.wikipedia.org]


4. Jeremiah Wright: Black liberation theology

Jeremiah Wright (born 1941) belongs to a related but substantially different tradition.

He was longtime pastor of Trinity United Church of Christ in Chicago, serving there for 36 years before retiring in 2008. He studied at Howard University, the University of Chicago Divinity School and United Theological Seminary and became associated particularly with Black theology/Black liberation theology. [en.wikipedia.org], [mccormick.edu]

This matters because Wright's theology shouldn't simply be described as "liberal."

His orientation is much more closely related to the tradition associated with theologians such as James Cone, in which Christianity is interpreted through African-American history and the experiences of racism, slavery, segregation, oppression and liberation. Wright was influenced by Cone. [en.wikipedia.org]

Trinity's famous identity under Wright was:

"Unashamedly Black and Unapologetically Christian." [aalbc.com], [mccormick.edu]

Wright became nationally controversial in 2008 because Barack Obama had attended Trinity and excerpts of Wright's provocative sermons were circulated during Obama's presidential campaign. [en.wikipedia.org]

But the theological genealogy is important:

Borg / Crossan → historical criticism and liberal Jesus scholarship

Spong → radical theological liberalism

Wright → Black church tradition + liberation theology + social critique

They overlap politically and sometimes theologically, but Wright comes from a very different historical experience.


5. United Church of Christ (UCC)

The United Church of Christ is probably the denomination on your list that most clearly exemplifies American mainline liberal Protestantism, although it contains considerable internal diversity.

It was created in 1957 through the union of several older Protestant traditions, especially the Congregational Christian Churches and Evangelical and Reformed Church. Its historical ancestry consequently includes New England Congregationalism/Puritanism, German Reformed Christianity and several other Protestant streams. [ucc.org], [britannica.com]

The UCC describes itself as Christian and Trinitarian, affirming God, the resurrected Christ and Holy Spirit, while also emphasizing that people are at different stages of spiritual journey and maintaining considerable room for theological diversity. [ucc.org]

An unusually important feature is congregational autonomy. A national UCC statement does not automatically dictate what every UCC congregation or member believes. [ucc.org], [britannica.com]

Its contemporary identity is strongly associated with:

  • ecumenism,

  • social justice,

  • racial justice,

  • LGBTQ inclusion,

  • women in ministry,

  • interfaith engagement,

  • theological pluralism,

  • historical-critical approaches to scripture.

Its well-known contemporary motto,"God is still speaking," captures its resistance to treating theological understanding as permanently closed. [ucc.org]

Jeremiah Wright therefore makes perfect sense institutionally in the UCC, although he represents its Black liberationist strand rather than standing for UCC theology as a whole.


6. Unitarian / Unitarian Universalism

This needs an important distinction.

Historically, Unitarianism was a form of liberal Christianity.

The name originally refers to rejecting the orthodox doctrine of the Trinity in favor of the unity of God. American Unitarianism developed particularly among intellectually liberal New England Congregationalists.

But modern Unitarian Universalism (UU) has moved substantially beyond being a Christian denomination.

Today's Unitarian Universalist Association explicitly says it has no shared creed. Its members can identify as Christian, Jewish, Buddhist, humanist, atheist/agnostic, Muslim, Pagan and other identities. Its shared framework is built around values including pluralism, justice, interdependence, transformation, generosity and equity, centered on love. [uua.org]

That gives us an important spectrum:

UCC:

"We are Christians, but Christianity permits enormous theological diversity."

Unitarian Universalism:

"Christianity is one legitimate spiritual path among several within our community."

That is a much larger theological step.

So I would call modern UU a post-Christian or multireligious descendant of American liberal Christianity, rather than simply another liberal Protestant Christian denomination.


7. Union Theological Seminary

Union Theological Seminary in New York is not a denomination. It is one of the historically most influential American seminaries associated with liberal and progressive Protestant theology.

It was founded in 1836 by Presbyterian ministers, but developed into an independent and ecumenical institution. Union describes itself today as rooted in the Protestant tradition while educating people "of all faiths and none," with a strong orientation toward social justice, activism, interreligious engagement and evolving understandings of faith. [utsnyc.edu]

That makes Union enormously important intellectually because seminaries are one of the places theological movements migrate between denominations.

For example, Marcus Borg studied there before going on to Oxford. [en.wikipedia.org], [anglicanch...enorca.com]

Historically, Union became associated with major currents including:

  • theological liberalism,

  • neo-orthodoxy,

  • Social Gospel/social ethics,

  • biblical criticism,

  • Black theology,

  • liberation theology,

  • feminist theology,

  • interfaith studies,

  • contemporary progressive theology.

So rather than imagining Union as a church, picture it as an intellectual crossroads that has influenced clergy and scholars across numerous American denominations.


8. "The Christian Left"

Finally, the Christian Left isn't a denomination or even one theology.

It is an umbrella description for Christians whose religious commitments tend to lead toward progressive or left-of-center social and political positions, particularly around poverty, economic inequality, racial justice, healthcare, immigration, peace, environmental concerns and marginalized groups. [en.wikipedia.org], [en.wikipedia.org]

Its American ancestry includes movements much older than today's Democratic/Republican alignment, particularly:

Hebrew prophets → teachings of Jesus → abolitionism → Social Gospel → labor reform → Civil Rights Movement → liberation theology → contemporary progressive Christianity

But here's the distinction I think is really important:

Theologically liberal ≠ politically liberal

A Christian can be:

theologically traditional + politically progressive

For example, someone might believe strongly in the resurrection, divinity of Christ and authority of scripture while understanding those commitments as requiring aggressive advocacy for immigrants, workers and the poor.

Conversely, someone could be:

theologically liberal + politically moderate

The Christian Left is principally a religious-political/social orientation; liberal Christianity is principally a theological and interpretive tradition. They overlap heavily, but they are not synonyms. [en.wikipedia.org], [en.wikipedia.org]


Putting all eight together

I think this is the cleanest conceptual map:

Figure/institution

Primary tradition

Key emphasis

Marcus Borg

Liberal/progressive Christianity

Historical Jesus + spiritual/metaphorical Christianity

John Dominic Crossan

Historical-critical scholarship

Recovering Jesus in Roman/Jewish social context

Shelby Spong

Radical liberal Christianity

Reconstruct Christianity beyond supernaturalism

Jeremiah Wright

Black liberation theology

Race, oppression, liberation, prophetic Christianity

Christian Left

Political/social movement

Social justice as Christian responsibility

UCC

Mainline Protestant denomination

Christian pluralism + social justice

Unitarian Universalism

Liberal religious tradition

Pluralistic, now broader than Christianity

Union Seminary

Ecumenical theological institution

Liberal/progressive theology + social ethics

And there is an even deeper historical distinction

I would divide what you're looking at into three branches of American religious liberalism:

1. Intellectual/theological liberalism
Bible criticism, science, modernity, historical Jesus
→ Borg, Crossan, Spong, Union.

2. Prophetic/social Christianity
Social Gospel, Civil Rights, liberation, racial/economic justice
→ Wright, Black liberation theology, much of the Christian Left, Union.

3. Religious pluralism
Christian particularism gradually gives way to wider spiritual/humanist pluralism
→ historical Unitarianism → modern Unitarian Universalism.

The UCC sits unusually close to the intersection of all three, while remaining explicitly Christian.

And that distinction may explain something that otherwise looks confusing: Borg, Crossan, Spong, and Wright can all look "liberal" from the standpoint of conservative evangelical Christianity while actually representing very different theological projects. Borg is trying to preserve a spiritually meaningful Christianity after historical criticism; Crossan is reconstructing the historical Jesus; Spong is radically reconstructing Christian doctrine; Wright is reading Christianity through Black history and liberation.

If you're exploring this because you're trying to understand where your own outlook might fit within the older American liberal-Christian spectrum, I can also map out the next layer: Unitarian → Congregationalist/UCC → Episcopal → ELCA → PCUSA → United Methodist → Disciples of Christ, showing how each differs on God, Jesus, resurrection, Bible, salvation, other religions, LGBTQ issues, and social justice. That comparison gets quite revealing.


Comments

intro

Popular Posts