Emergent Liberal
Emergent Liberal
The Emerging/Emergent Church was less a denomination than a network and conversation that became especially visible in the late 1990s and 2000s. It arose largely among evangelicals asking how Christianity should function in a postmodern, post-Christendom culture. Common themes included dissatisfaction with megachurch consumerism, suspicion of rigid theological certainty, conversational rather than authoritarian leadership, experimentation with worship and community, and renewed interest in social justice. [cbn.com], [sanity.war...nmedia.com]
There's also a useful distinction between"emerging church" as the broad phenomenon and Emergent/Emergent Village as a particular network within it. The boundaries were always fuzzy.
And crucially, Emergent didn't begin simply as:
"Let's become liberal Christians."
It was more:
"The evangelical framework we inherited isn't adequate anymore. What happens if we're allowed to rethink it?"
For some, that eventually resulted in something recognizably close to progressive Christianity. Others remained more identifiably evangelical.
1. Brian McLaren
Brian McLaren is probably the single most important theological interpreter of the Emergent movement.
He was born in 1956 and raised in the conservative Open Brethren/Plymouth Brethren tradition. He became involved with the Jesus Movement, earned bachelor's and master's degrees in English from the University of Maryland, taught English, and helped found Cedar Ridge Community Church in Maryland in 1982. He served as its founding pastor until 2006. [en.wikipedia.org]
That's significant: McLaren wasn't a liberal seminary professor who decided to critique evangelicalism. He came from inside conservative evangelical Christianity.
His early books began asking how Christianity might work in a postmodern world. A New Kind of Christian, A Generous Orthodoxy, The Secret Message of Jesus and eventually A New Kind of Christianity progressively challenged conventional evangelical assumptions. [en.wikipedia.org], [cbn.com]
His trajectory broadly moved from:
Evangelicalism → Emergent Christianity → progressive/post-evangelical Christianity → contemplative and interfaith-friendly Christianity.
Today he is associated with the Center for Action and Contemplation, the organization founded by Richard Rohr. [en.wikipedia.org]
McLaren's emphasis increasingly became Jesus' kingdom as a way of life here and now, rather than Christianity primarily as the mechanism by which individuals avoid hell and reach heaven.
In that respect, you can see the connection with Marcus Borg, although they arrived from opposite directions:
Borg: mainline academic liberalism → accessible progressive Christianity.
McLaren: conservative evangelicalism → questioning → Emergent → progressive Christianity.
2. Rob Bell
Rob Bell is probably the most culturally successful figure to emerge from this world.
Bell came through very recognizable evangelical institutions: Wheaton College and Fuller Theological Seminary. In 1999 he founded Mars Hill Bible Church in Michigan, which grew into a megachurch with thousands attending each Sunday. He also became famous through the beautifully produced NOOMA short films. [en.wikipedia.org]
But Bell's preaching increasingly asked people to question the assumptions underneath familiar Christian language.
Velvet Elvis (2005) was an early marker.
Then came Love Wins in 2011.
Bell questioned evangelical assumptions concerning hell and the idea that only those who explicitly accept Jesus before death can experience salvation. The resulting controversy produced accusations that Bell was advocating universalism, although the book itself explored possibilities rather than simply announcing a systematic doctrine of universal salvation. [en.wikipedia.org], [christiant...day.com.au]
For many evangelical Christians, Love Wins was the moment Bell crossed the line.
Bell subsequently left Mars Hill and increasingly moved outside conventional church structures into podcasts, books, speaking, performance and broader spirituality. [en.wikipedia.org]
His trajectory therefore looks something like:
Evangelical megachurch pastor → Emergent-adjacent Christianity → progressive Christianity → expansive contemporary spirituality.
Bell is less systematic than McLaren. He's more poet/storyteller/communicator.
If McLaren writes:
"Let's reconsider the theological system."
Bell tends to say:
"Wait. Look at this thing you've always assumed. What if there is another way of seeing it?"
3. Tony Jones
Tony Jones represents the more explicitly theological and postmodern-philosophical side of Emergent.
He studied classics at Dartmouth, earned an M.Div. at Fuller Theological Seminary with interests in systematic theology and postmodern philosophy, and pursued doctoral study in practical theology at Princeton. He served as National Coordinator of Emergent Village from 2005 to 2008 and as theologian-in-residence at Doug Pagitt's Solomon's Porch congregation. [theopedia.com], [theoblogy....dpress.com]
His books included Postmodern Youth Ministry, The Sacred Way, The New Christians, The Church Is Flat, and A Better Atonement. [alchetron.com], [theoblogy....dpress.com]
Jones' emphasis is particularly helpful for understanding the intellectual foundations of Emergent:
modern Christianity:
"Here is the correct theological answer."
postmodern/Emergent sensibility:
"Who constructed that answer? From what perspective? How does community, language, history and culture affect what we believe we're seeing?"
This doesn't necessarily mean "there is no truth." Rather it challenges the assumption that our interpretation of truth is identical with truth itself.
That connects rather strongly to what you were saying yesterday about your preference for relativism and suspension of belief rather than absolutist claims that something is simply true.
That epistemological humility is one of the most important threads running through Emergent Christianity.
4. Doug Pagitt
Doug Pagitt is the church-community experimenter of the movement.
He founded Solomon's Porch in Minneapolis and was also a founding figure in Emergent Village. Instead of traditional sermons in which one authoritative pastor explains biblical truth to a passive audience, Pagitt developed a consciously dialogical approach where people participate in the theological conversation. [en.wikipedia.org]
That signifies something deeper than worship style.
Traditional evangelical model:
pastor → possesses/explains correct interpretation → congregation receives it.
Pagitt's model:
community → encounters scripture/experience together → meaning emerges through conversation.
He wrote books including Reimagining Spiritual Formation, Preaching Re-Imagined, A Christianity Worth Believing and Flipped. More recently his work has moved explicitly into progressive Christianity and political engagement; in 2018 he founded Vote Common Good, which organizes progressive religious voters. [en.wikipedia.org]
So Pagitt connects:
Emergent ecclesiology → participatory Christianity → generous/progressive Christianity → contemporary Christian political activism.
5. Tim Conder
Tim Conder is less famous publicly, but he's significant in understanding Emergent as a movement.
He was one of the founding leaders of Emergent Village and founded Emmaus Way in Durham, North Carolina. His academic and ministry interests increasingly centered on cultural studies, race, social movements, community organizing and social justice. [patheos.com], [tim-conder...espace.com]
His books and contributions include The Church in Transition, Free for All: Rediscovering the Bible in Community, and work in The Emergent Manifesto of Hope. [organizingchurch.com], [chalicepress.com]
Conder is especially interesting because he demonstrates another Emergent trajectory:
rethinking church → rethinking authority → communal biblical interpretation → social justice → community organizing.
His later academic work has dealt with Christianity, race and social-justice activism, including engagement with North Carolina's Moral Movement. [organizingchurch.com], [shawu.academia.edu]
He has also had a direct connection with The Seattle School of Theology & Psychology, serving as a trustee and later Trustee Emeritus. [patheos.com], [chalicepress.com]
6. Spencer Burke
Spencer Burke represents perhaps the most experimental and boundary-pushing end of early Emergent Christianity.
He had been a teaching pastor at the large evangelical Mariners Church and then created TheOoze.com, an early online community where people questioned and discussed emerging forms of Christianity. [en.wikipedia.org], [Spencer Bu...cal Guide”]
This was important in the pre-social-media Internet era. TheOoze allowed geographically scattered people who were independently thinking,
"Traditional church doesn't make sense to me anymore"
to discover one another.
Burke wrote A Heretic's Guide to Eternity and intentionally reclaimed"heretic" in something like its constructive-dissenter meaning: someone inside a religious community who questions its settled assumptions because they care about it. [Spencer Bu...cal Guide”]
His evolving approach emphasized theological diversity, experimentation and holding beliefs strongly enough to live by them but lightly enough to allow them to change. [Spencer Bu...cal Guide”]
Burke therefore represents the religious innovation / spiritual experimentation side of Emergent more than conventional denominational theology.
7. Emergent Village
Emergent Village was the network that connected many of these people.
Doug Pagitt was among its founders, while figures including Brian McLaren, Tim Conder, Tony Jones and other emerging-church leaders participated in its development and leadership. Tony Jones served as National Coordinator from 2005–2008. [en.wikipedia.org], [alchetron.com], [patheos.com]
Calling it an "organization" almost gives the wrong impression because network and conversation were themselves part of the theology.
It deliberately resisted:
rigid doctrinal boundaries,
centralized authority,
denominational bureaucracy,
single authoritative leaders,
certainty as the mark of faith.
And emphasized:
friendship,
conversation,
experimentation,
postmodern thought,
missional Christianity,
community,
justice,
questioning.
That decentralization was simultaneously one of its greatest innovations and one reason Emergent was incredibly difficult to define.
8. Wild Goose Festival
The Wild Goose Festival is almost what happened when this theological conversation acquired music, tents, art, activism and a festival campground.
It began in 2011, inspired by Britain's longstanding Greenbelt Festival. The first Wild Goose brought together figures including Brian McLaren, Jim Wallis, Richard Rohr, Phyllis Tickle, Doug Pagitt, Tony Jones, Shane Claiborne and Nadia Bolz-Weber. [en.wikipedia.org], [wildgoosef...stival.org]
Wild Goose describes its original intersection beautifully simply:
justice + spirituality + art. [wildgoosef...stival.org]
It has continued as an annual event rooted in progressive Christianity and social justice while welcoming people from other faiths or no religious faith. Its programming includes music, storytelling, theology, meditation, art and issues involving marginalized communities and political/social justice. [en.wikipedia.org], [episcopaln...ervice.org]
And it is still alive. The 2025 festival included discussions of Indigenous voices, neurodivergence, LGBTQ+ ministry, Christian nationalism and the death penalty; Wild Goose has also announced programming for 2026. [episcopaln...ervice.org], [wildgoosef...stival.org]
So if Emergent Village was the network, you might think of Wild Goose as one of the cultural descendants of the movement.
9. The Seattle School of Theology & Psychology
This one I suspect might especially interest you professionally.
The Seattle School of Theology & Psychology began in 1997, originally under the auspices of Western Seminary. It later became independent and was known as Mars Hill Graduate School before adopting its present name in 2011. [en.wikipedia.org], [theseattleschool.edu]
Important clarification: this Mars Hill was not Rob Bell's Mars Hill Bible Church. The shared name creates endless confusion.
The founding circle included psychologist/theologian Dan Allender and others who wanted education at the intersection of:
Bible + human soul + contemporary culture. [theseattleschool.edu]
Today the Seattle School describes itself as an interdisciplinary graduate school and seminary integrating counseling psychology, theology and culture, educating therapists as well as pastors, artists and leaders. Its institutional language describes an approach that is "robustly Christian, deeply questioning, and profoundly human." [theseattleschool.edu]
That's actually a very good encapsulation of the larger milieu.
The connections to Emergent aren't merely conceptual. Tim Conder served as a trustee, and Brian McLaren has also had connections with its governance. [watchman.org], [patheos.com]
Theologically and psychologically, the Seattle School emphasizes relationship, narrative, cultural context, human brokenness, trauma, formation and personal story, rather than simply dividing education into "correct theology" on one side and secular psychotherapy on the other. Its institutional history explicitly describes its original project as an integration of theology, psychology, and culture. [theseattleschool.edu], [theseattleschool.edu]
Given your own background as a therapist and your interest in how narrative, trauma, psychology, meaning-making, spirituality and different interpretive frameworks interact, this may actually be the institution on your list that has the most direct overlap with your professional world.
The big contrast with the Classic Liberals
This is where your two lists become really interesting.
Classic Liberal trajectory
Traditional Protestantism
↓
Enlightenment/science/historical criticism
↓
Liberal theology
↓
Borg / Spong / Union / UCC
↓
Progressive Christianity
Emergent trajectory
20th-century Evangelical Christianity
↓
Evangelical megachurch / youth ministry culture
↓
"Something about this isn't working"
↓
postmodernism + questioning certainty
↓
McLaren / Bell / Pagitt / Jones / Conder / Burke
↓
Emergent conversation
↓
social justice + inclusion + contemplative spirituality + theological pluralism
↓
Post-Evangelical / Progressive Christianity
And then the two streams begin converging.
That's why people such as Marcus Borg, Richard Rohr, Brian McLaren, Rob Bell, Diana Butler Bass, Nadia Bolz-Weber, Doug Pagitt and the Wild Goose community increasingly start showing up in overlapping progressive-Christian spaces even though they originated in considerably different Christian environments.
.png)

.png)

Comments
Post a Comment