Progressive Evangelical









Donald Miller, Jim Wallis, Rachel Held Evans, Nadia Bolz Weber, Jay Bakker, Peter Enns, Leroy Barber, Miroslav Volf, Red Letter Christians, Sojourners, George Fox University, Eastern University

"Donald Miller Donald Miller is a Christian author and public speaker based out of Portland, Oregon. He is the founder of The Belmont Foundation, "a not-for-profit foundation which partners with local churches to create mentoring programs for young men growing up without fathers."

James E. Wallis Jr. (born June 4, 1948) is an American theologian, writer, teacher and political activist. He is best known as the founder and editor of Sojourners magazine and as the founder of the Washington, D.C.-based Christian community of the same name. 

Rachel Held Evans (née Rachel Grace Held; June 8, 1981 – May 4, 2019) was an American Christian columnist, blogger and author. Her book A Year of Biblical Womanhood was a New York Times bestseller in e-book non-fiction, and Searching for Sunday was a New York Times bestseller nonfiction paperback.

Nadia Bolz-Weber (born April 22, 1969) is an author, Lutheran minister and public theologian. She served as the founding pastor of House for All Sinners and Saints, a congregation of the Evangelical Lutheran Church in America in Denver, Colorado, until July 8, 2018.

Jamie Charles "Jay" Bakker (born December 18, 1975) is an American pastor, author, and speaker. He is the son of televangelists Jim Bakker and Tammy Faye Messner.

Peter Eric Enns (born January 2, 1961) is an American Biblical scholar and theologian. He has written widely on hermeneutics, Christianity and science, historicity of the Bible, and Old Testament interpretation. Outside of his academic work Enns is a contributor to HuffPost and Patheos. 

Leroy Barber has dedicated more than 20 years to eradicating poverty, confronting homelessness, restoring local neighborhoods, healing racism, and living what Dr. King called “the beloved community.” Leroy starts projects that shape society; in 1989, burdened by the plight of Philadelphia’s homeless, he and his wife Donna founded Restoration Ministries, to serve homeless families and children living on the streets. In 1994 he became Director of Internship Programs at Cornerstone Christian Academy. Leroy was licensed and ordained at Mt Zion Baptist Church where he served as Youth Director with Donna, and also served as Associate Minister of Evangelism.  


Miroslav Volf (born September 25, 1956) is a Croatian Protestant theologian and public intellectual and Henry B. Wright Professor of Theology and Director of the Yale Center for Faith and Culture at Yale University. He previously taught at the Evangelical Theological Seminary in his native Osijek, Croatia (1979–80, 1983–90) and Fuller Theological Seminary in Pasadena, California (1990–1998).

Red-Letter Christians constitute a non-denominational movement within Christianity. "Red-Letter" refers to New Testament verses and parts of verses printed in red ink, to indicate the words attributed to Jesus without the use of quotations.

Sojourners is a progressive monthly magazine and daily online publication of the American Christian social justice organization Sojourners, which arose out of the Sojourners Community. It was first published in 1971 under the original title of The Post-American. 

George Fox University is a private Christian university in Newberg, Oregon. Founded as a school for Quakers in 1891, it is now the largest private university in Oregon with more than 4,000 students combined between its main campus in Newberg, its centers in Portland, and Redmond, and online.

Eastern University (EU) is a private Christian university in St. Davids, Pennsylvania, with additional locations in Philadelphia and Harrisburg. The university offers undergraduate, graduate, and seminary programs. Eastern University is affiliated with the American Baptist Churches USA and has an interdenominational student body, faculty and administration.

Progressive Evangelical

This is another distinct stream in the family tree you are constructing. I would call these figures Progressive Evangelical or Post-Evangelical rather than classic liberal Christians. They generally retain a stronger attachment to Jesus, Scripture, conversion, discipleship, and evangelical spirituality than classic theological liberals, while rejecting or substantially revising the conservative evangelical package around politics, biblical inerrancy, patriarchy, LGBTQ exclusion, race, science, and sometimes atonement and hell.

A useful lineage is:

Evangelical Christianity
↓
Civil Rights / evangelical social justice / evangelical feminism
↓
Progressive Evangelicalism
↓
Emergent + post-evangelical deconstruction
↓
Today's progressive Christian ecosystem

There is considerable overlap with the Emergent people we just discussed, but the center of gravity is somewhat different.


1. Donald Miller

Donald Miller is actually difficult to label "progressive evangelical" theologically. His importance is more cultural and autobiographical.

His 2003 Blue Like Jazz: Nonreligious Thoughts on Christian Spirituality became a major book among younger Christians dissatisfied with evangelical subculture. Much of it drew from Miller's experiences around Portland and Reed College and presented Christianity through personal stories, doubts, relationships, authenticity and spirituality rather than systematic doctrine. [en.wikipedia.org], [christiani...ytoday.com]

That was enormously important in the early 2000s.

Miller represented:

"I like Jesus. I'm uncomfortable with Christian culture."

rather than:

"I've concluded traditional Christian theology is intellectually untenable."

That's an important difference from Spong or Borg.

Blue Like Jazz sold more than a million copies and became strongly associated with the emerging/postmodern Christian milieu. [en.wikipedia.org], [christiani...ytoday.com]

Because you're in the Portland area, there's also a fascinating Pacific Northwest component here. Miller's Reed College encounters gave Blue Like Jazz much of its particular character. Portland's overwhelmingly secular environment forced him to reconsider what evangelical Christianity looked like from the outside. [en.wikipedia.org]

Think: post-evangelical memoirist / authenticity / Jesus without evangelical culture.


2. Jim Wallis

I think you meant Jim Wallis rather than "Jim Walls."

Wallis is tremendously important because he predates Emergent by decades.

Born in 1948 and raised in a Midwestern evangelical family, Wallis became troubled by racial segregation, became involved with Black churches in Detroit, and participated in civil-rights and antiwar activism while at Michigan State. He subsequently attended conservative Trinity Evangelical Divinity School. [en.wikipedia.org], [sojo.net], [britannica.com]

In 1971 he and other seminarians started a publication called The Post-American, which eventually became Sojourners. The community moved to Washington, D.C., in 1975. [sojo.net], [britannica.com]

Wallis' basic argument has remained remarkably consistent:

Christian faith should not belong to the political Right or Left. The gospel should critique both, particularly where power conflicts with Jesus' concern for poor and oppressed people.

However, his positions on poverty, racism, war, immigration, economic justice, environmental issues and Christian nationalism have placed him squarely in what gets described as the evangelical left/Christian left. He nevertheless continues to identify with evangelical Christianity. [en.wikipedia.org], [sojo.net]

Today he holds the Archbishop Desmond Tutu Chair in Faith and Justice at Georgetown and leads its Center on Faith and Justice. [sojo.net]

Think: evangelical faith + prophetic politics + social justice.

Wallis is essentially an elder statesman of progressive evangelicalism.


3. Rachel Held Evans

Rachel Held Evans (1981-2019) represents the next generation extraordinarily well.

She was raised in a traditional Southern Baptist environment, attended evangelical Bryan College in Tennessee, and began publicly wrestling with questions about evolution, hell, women, biblical authority and evangelical certainty. [equip.org], [koinoniafarm.org]

Her breakthrough book, A Year of Biblical Womanhood, used an intentionally literal attempt to follow biblical instructions concerning women to expose how much interpretation and selectivity goes into claims that Christians simply "follow the Bible." [equip.org], [koinoniafarm.org]

That connects directly with the epistemological theme we identified in Emergent Christianity.

Evans increasingly advocated:

  • women's equality and ordination,

  • LGBTQ inclusion,

  • acceptance of evolution,

  • room for doubt,

  • less rigid understandings of biblical authority,

  • inclusion of marginalized Christians. [koinoniafarm.org]

But she didn't simply discard Christianity or Scripture. She continued wrestling with them. Eventually she left evangelicalism institutionally and became Episcopalian; Searching for Sunday documents much of that transition. [equip.org]

Her death in 2019 at only 37 produced an extraordinary response across progressive/post-evangelical Christianity. Her funeral itself illustrated that ecosystem, including her friend Nadia Bolz-Weber. [ncronline.org]

Think: evangelical deconstruction without abandoning Jesus.

Of everyone on this list, Evans may most clearly represent the people who say:

"I didn't lose my faith. I lost the certainty with which I had been taught I was required to hold it."


4. Nadia Bolz-Weber

Nadia Bolz-Weber is different because she isn't really evangelical denominationally.

She's an ordained Lutheran pastor and founder of House for All Sinners & Saints in Denver. Her books include Pastrix, Accidental Saints, and Shameless. [nadiabolzweber.com], [nadiabolzweber.com]

But she became hugely influential among progressive evangelicals and ex-evangelicals because of her decidedly unpolished theology of grace.

She openly writes and speaks about:

  • addiction and recovery,

  • personal failure,

  • sexuality,

  • shame,

  • forgiveness,

  • doubt,

  • grace and mercy. [nadiabolzweber.com]

Interestingly, she can sometimes sound more classically Lutheran than liberal:

Humans are screwed up.
We hurt ourselves and each other.
Grace isn't a reward for getting ourselves together.
That's precisely why we need grace.

So she's progressive socially but retains a strong theology of sin, grace, Christ, forgiveness and sacrament.

That's quite different from Spong.

Think: radically inclusive Lutheran grace.


5. Jay Bakker

Jay Bakker has one of the more unusual biographies here.

He is the son of televangelists Jim Bakker and Tammy Faye Messner. He was 12 when his father's ministry collapsed amid scandal and criminal prosecution. The resulting ostracism from parts of the Christian community profoundly affected him; he subsequently went through his own period of substance abuse and disillusionment with institutional Christianity. [en.wikipedia.org]

He eventually co-founded Revolution Church, developing an explicitly inclusive Christianity particularly welcoming people who had experienced religious rejection. His theology became much more liberal than his parents' evangelical world, including support for LGBTQ inclusion and same-sex marriage and questioning traditional understandings of atonement and salvation. [en.wikipedia.org]

And there's a poignant connection here: Tammy Faye herself became remembered for compassion toward gay people and people with AIDS when much conservative American Christianity stigmatized both.

Jay's emphasis magnifies that impulse:

grace > religious exclusion.

Think: evangelical celebrity culture's wounded child becomes radical grace/inclusion pastor.


6. Peter Enns

Peter Enns is one of the most important people on your list intellectually.

He's a biblical scholar rather than primarily an activist. He studied at Messiah College, Westminster Theological Seminary and then Harvard, earning his Ph.D. in Near Eastern Languages and Civilizations. [en.wikipedia.org], [eastern.edu]

His major breakthrough and controversy was Inspiration and Incarnation.

Enns argues essentially that if Christians believe Jesus is simultaneously human and divine, they might analogously understand Scripture as genuinely divine and genuinely human.

That means the Bible reflects:

  • ancient cultures,

  • ancient assumptions,

  • different authors,

  • different perspectives,

  • literary conventions,

  • historical contexts.

His work created a major conflict at conservative Westminster Theological Seminary and ultimately contributed to his departure. [en.wikipedia.org]

He subsequently wrote The Evolution of Adam, The Bible Tells Me So, and The Sin of Certainty, and co-hosts The Bible for Normal People. Today he is Abram S. Clemens Professor of Biblical Studies at Eastern University. [eastern.edu], [drpeteenns.com]

Of the people you've listed across all three groups, I suspect Enns might particularly interest you.

His fundamental distinction is rather close to one you repeatedly make:

Our interpretation of something is not identical to the thing itself.

Enns isn't saying "the Bible is meaningless."

He's asking why trust in God must require certainty about our interpretations of the Bible.

Think: evangelical biblical scholarship after inerrancy.


7. Leroy Barber

Leroy Barber represents the racial reconciliation, community development and social-justice strand.

His ministry has included work with homelessness, children and low-income communities; he founded Restoration Ministries with his wife Donna, worked with FCS Urban Ministries and Atlanta Youth Academies, helped found several community initiatives, and has been involved with the Christian Community Development Association. [sojo.net], [neighborho...nomics.org]

A central theme is Martin Luther King Jr.'s idea of the"beloved community." His writing deals heavily with race, reconciliation, neighborhoods, mission and what he calls radical shalom. [neighborho...nomics.org], [ivpress.com]

Barber therefore brings something essential to this movement:

Progressive evangelicalism isn't just white evangelicals discovering that conservative evangelicalism is too restrictive.

There is also a longstanding Black evangelical/protestant critique asking why evangelical Christianity can talk endlessly about personal salvation while failing to confront structural racism, poverty and segregation.

Think: evangelical mission transformed into community development + racial/economic justice.


8. Miroslav Volf

Miroslav Volf is really in a category of his own.

He's a Croatian-born Protestant theologian, educated in Croatia, at Fuller Seminary, and at Germany's University of Tübingen, where he studied under major theologian Jürgen Moltmann. He now holds the Henry B. Wright Professorship of Systematic Theology at Yale Divinity School and founded the Yale Center for Faith & Culture. [divinity.yale.edu], [faith.yale.edu]

He grew up Pentecostal in communist Yugoslavia, as a religious minority surrounded predominantly by Catholic and Orthodox populations and under a Marxist political system suspicious of Christianity. [en.wikipedia.org]

That background substantially informs his preoccupation with:

identity + difference + reconciliation + violence + forgiveness + pluralism.

His classic work Exclusion and Embrace explores how we maintain identity while making room for the Other. It won the Grawemeyer Award and became a major contemporary theological work. [divinity.yale.edu], [faith.yale.edu]

He's also heavily involved in Christian-Muslim and other interreligious dialogue while remaining identifiably Christian. He belongs both to the Episcopal Church in the U.S. and the Evangelical Church in Croatia. [divinity.yale.edu]

Volf therefore represents the serious academic theological end of this ecosystem.

Think: orthodox-ish Christianity + pluralism + reconciliation + public theology.

I wouldn't characterize him simply as a "liberal theologian." He's considerably more traditional theologically than someone like Spong.


9. Red Letter Christians

Red Letter Christians began in 2007 around Tony Campolo, Shane Claiborne, and Christians concerned that "evangelical" had become increasingly synonymous with a conservative political voting bloc. [en.wikipedia.org], [redletterc...stians.org]

The name comes from Bibles in which Jesus' words are printed in red.

Their question is intentionally simple:

What if American Christians actually organized their social priorities around what Jesus talks about?

That tends to foreground:

It's particularly useful for understanding Progressive Evangelicalism versus classic Liberal Christianity.

Red Letter Christians aren't primarily arguing:

"Modern biblical criticism demonstrates that traditional Christian doctrine is untenable."

They're saying:

"We take Jesus seriously, and that's exactly why we think conservative Christian politics have gotten the priorities wrong."

That's a radically different genealogy.


10. Sojourners

Sojourners is the older institutional ancestor of much of this.

It began among students at Trinity Evangelical Divinity School in the early 1970s who were struggling with Christianity's relationship to the Vietnam War and political/social ethics. In 1971 they created The Post-American. The community moved to Washington, D.C., in 1975 and became Sojourners. [sojo.net], [britannica.com]

Early members actually lived communally, sharing resources while running neighborhood programs and working around poverty, housing, peace and justice. Later it transitioned from intentional community into the nonprofit organization and media platform that exists today. [sojo.net]

Its current work remains centered on Christianity and social justice, including race, poverty, peace, climate, democracy and other public issues. [sojo.net], [sojo.net]

So:

Sojourners = the institution/media voice

Jim Wallis = its founding figure

Red Letter Christians = related Jesus-centered movement

There is substantial overlap.


11. George Fox University

And here we're suddenly very close to home for you: Newberg, Oregon.

George Fox University has Quaker/Friends roots, beginning as Friends Pacific Academy in 1885 and Pacific College in 1891. It became George Fox College in 1949, named after the founder of the Quaker movement, and George Fox University after merging with Western Evangelical Seminary in 1996. [georgefox.edu]

The Quaker heritage matters.

Historically, Friends emphasized:

  • personal experience of God's presence,

  • relative resistance to ecclesiastical hierarchy,

  • equality,

  • peacemaking,

  • abolitionism,

  • women's participation in ministry.

George Fox, however, belongs specifically to the evangelical wing of contemporary Quakerism, rather than the very liberal/unprogrammed Quaker tradition some people associate with modern Friends. [gfucrescent.com], [en.wikipedia.org]

So I wouldn't call George Fox University straightforwardly a progressive evangelical university.

It's better described as:

Evangelical Christian university with Quaker roots and some intellectual/cultural space in which conversations associated with progressive evangelicalism can occur.

That distinction is important.


12. Eastern University

Eastern University is a much cleaner institutional example of the particular tradition you're investigating.

Its origins are Baptist. Eastern Baptist Theological Seminary was founded in Philadelphia in 1925 by Baptist ministers. Fascinatingly, the institution historically described its vision as:

"conservative, yet progressive." [eastern.edu], [palmerseminary.edu]

And they meant something specific by that.

The founders maintained a high view of Scripture but considered other conservative seminaries too narrow regarding women's ministry and too inattentive to social justice. [palmerseminary.edu]

That's practically the DNA of Progressive Evangelicalism.

Eastern Baptist College developed from the seminary in 1952, became Eastern College in 1972 and Eastern University in 2001. The seminary eventually reunited with Eastern and is now Palmer Theological Seminary. [palmerseminary.edu], [catalog.eastern.edu]

Eastern's motto summarizes the tradition beautifully:

Faith, Reason and Justice

It remains Christian and historically Baptist, associated with American Baptist Churches USA, rather than becoming a secularized former-Christian institution. [en.wikipedia.org]

And now you see why Peter Enns teaching there makes structural sense. He's exactly the kind of scholar who inhabits that tension:

serious Christian commitment + serious scholarship + permission to question inherited evangelical assumptions. [eastern.edu]


Comments

intro

Popular Posts