Neo-Evangelical
Neo-Evangelical
Yes. This fourth group helps clarify something that was blurry in the Emergent discussion. I would use“Neo-Evangelical” here to mean evangelicals who consciously engage postmodern/secular culture, biblical scholarship, social concerns, and new forms of church while generally trying to remain within historic evangelical or orthodox Christian boundaries. It is not a universally accepted label for all of these people.
Their basic stance is often:
“The culture has changed, and some evangelical methods and formulations need reconsideration. But that does not mean abandoning historic Christian faith.”
That makes this group an important bridge between traditional evangelicalism and Emergent/progressive Christianity.
1. Scot McKnight
Scot McKnight is one of the strongest scholarly voices in this category. He trained at Grand Rapids Baptist College, Trinity Evangelical Divinity School, and the University of Nottingham, where his doctoral supervisor was major New Testament scholar James D. G. Dunn. He taught at Trinity, North Park, and Northern Seminary and became an ordained Anglican deacon and canon theologian. [en.wikipedia.org]
McKnight participated sympathetically in early conversations around the Emerging Church, but his theology remained much more clearly connected to historic Christianity than the increasingly progressive wing of Emergent. [theopedia.com]
Books such as The Jesus Creed, The Blue Parakeet, The King Jesus Gospel, Kingdom Conspiracy, and A Church Called Tov show his recurring concerns: Jesus, biblical interpretation, what "gospel" actually means, the nature of Christian community, and healthier church culture. [en.wikipedia.org], [tyndalechr...yndale.com]
A particularly important McKnight distinction is:
The gospel is bigger than the evangelical formula of "how an individual gets saved."
The gospel is the story of Jesus as Messiah and Lord within Israel's larger story. That places McKnight relatively close to N. T. Wright.
Think: evangelical biblical scholar who thinks evangelicalism has sometimes reduced the Gospel too much.
2. Dan Kimball
Dan Kimball is an unusually revealing case because he was a prominent early Emerging Church figure who did not follow Emergent into theological progressivism.
Kimball didn't grow up Christian. He played in punk/rockabilly music, became curious about Christianity in young adulthood, and eventually became a Christian after serious exploration of whether the Bible and Christianity were historically credible. He later earned degrees from Western Seminary and George Fox University and founded Vintage Faith Church in Santa Cruz in 2004. [vintagechurch.org], [dankimball.com]
He argued that churches needed to rethink worship, preaching, evangelism and church culture for a post-Christian culture, but importantly, he maintained that historic Christian doctrines themselves did not need to be discarded. [en.wikipedia.org]
That distinction separates his version of "emerging" from McLaren's eventual trajectory:
McLaren: the theological framework itself requires reconstruction.
Kimball: the way we communicate and embody historic Christianity requires reconstruction.
His later How (Not) to Read the Bible tackles troubling biblical passages involving violence, slavery, women, science, etc., while attempting to preserve confidence in Christianity rather than dismantle it. [vintagechurch.org], [dankimball.com]
Think: culturally innovative but theologically orthodox Emerging Christianity.
3. N. T. Wright
N. T. Wright is actually British Anglican rather than American evangelical, but his influence on American Neo-Evangelical and post-evangelical Christianity has been enormous.
Wright is a New Testament scholar, Pauline theologian and former Bishop of Durham in the Church of England. He studied at Oxford, was ordained in 1975, served as Bishop of Durham from 2003 to 2010, later taught at St Andrews, and is now a Senior Research Fellow at Wycliffe Hall, Oxford. [en.wikipedia.org], [theology.ox.ac.uk]
Wright is associated with the New Perspective on Paul and with historically grounded reconsiderations of justification, resurrection, eschatology and the kingdom of God. [en.wikipedia.org]
He strongly affirms the resurrection. This is important because he isn't doing what Crossan or Spong do.
Compare:
Crossan: What historically lies behind later resurrection claims?
Spong: How can resurrection be reconceived nonliterally?
Wright: What did first-century Jews and Christians mean by resurrection, and what historical explanation best accounts for early Christian belief that Jesus actually rose?
His Surprised by Hope particularly challenges the popular evangelical picture that Christianity is basically about souls going to heaven after death. Wright emphasizes bodily resurrection and new creation, with God's kingdom transforming creation rather than abandoning it. [en.wikipedia.org], [cslewisinstitute.org]
Think: historically sophisticated orthodoxy that sometimes upends popular evangelical theology.
4. Rick McKinley
Rick McKinley is especially relevant to your list because he is another Portland figure.
McKinley moved to Portland in 2000 to plant Imago Dei Community, which became an influential church identified with arts, urban engagement, service and mission. He also helped create Advent Conspiracy and Love Portland. [theworkoft...people.com], [outreachmagazine.com]
McKinley's understanding of the Kingdom illustrates Neo-Evangelical thinking particularly well. He explicitly holds together personal redemption through Christ and generous service of one's neighbors, resisting the idea that Christianity must choose between evangelism and social action. [kenwytsma.com]
So:
conservative evangelicalism sometimes emphasized personal salvation;
mainline liberalism often emphasized social transformation;
people like McKinley say why are those opposites?
That's a recurring Neo-Evangelical insight.
Think: Kingdom of God + Portland + missional church + social engagement without abandoning conversion.
5. Dave Ferguson
Dave Ferguson represents the church multiplication/organizational innovation wing.
He co-founded Chicago's Community Christian Church, a multi-site missional congregation, and became a major leader in NewThing and Exponential, networks devoted to church planting and multiplying Christian leaders and communities. [daveferguson.org], [exponential.org]
His emphasis isn't principally theological deconstruction. It is:
How do we make churches reproducible movements rather than institutions dependent upon one charismatic pastor?
Hence books and ideas around Exponential, Hero Maker, B.L.E.S.S. and multiplying leaders. [exponential.org], [davefergus...bstack.com]
He remains much more conventionally evangelical than Bell, McLaren or Evans.
Think: evangelical church planting transformed through networks and multiplication.
6. Jonathan Merritt
Jonathan Merritt, usually known as Jon or Jonathan Merritt, represents the faith-and-culture journalism strand.
His background is strongly evangelical: his M.Div. is from Southeastern Baptist Theological Seminary. But he subsequently earned an M.Th. at Emory's Candler School of Theology and pursued additional work in Christian mysticism at the Episcopal General Theological Seminary. [jonathanmerritt.com], [simonandsc...ishing.com]
His writing increasingly explored Christianity beyond the culture wars, including books such as A Faith of Our Own, Jesus Is Better Than You Imagined, and Learning to Speak God from Scratch. He became a prominent religion journalist and is now a vice president and executive editor at Simon & Schuster overseeing religion, faith and spirituality acquisitions. [jonathanmerritt.com], [simonandsc...ishing.com]
Merritt therefore sits closer to the post-evangelical edge of this category than Keller.
Think: Southern evangelical formation → broader theological culture → journalism about faith beyond the culture wars.
7. Erwin McManus
Erwin McManus is Salvadoran-American, immigrated to the United States as a child, and became the pastor associated with Mosaic in Los Angeles. He became prominent for speaking about postmodern Christianity, culture, creativity and leadership. [en.wikipedia.org], [erwinmcmanus.com]
Mosaic intentionally fuses Christianity with art, creativity, entrepreneurship, culture and innovation and describes itself as centered on Jesus while understanding church as a movement rather than merely someplace one attends. [mosaic.org]
McManus increasingly sounds as much like a creativity/leadership/personal-development teacher as a traditional pastor. His contemporary work includes coaching leaders and entrepreneurs as well as Christian ministry. [erwinmcmanus.com]
Think: evangelical Christianity reframed through creativity, culture, imagination and human potential.
8. Tim Keller
Tim Keller (1950–2023) is very important because he illustrates why Neo-Evangelical does not mean progressive theology.
Keller was a conservative Reformed Presbyterian minister in the Presbyterian Church in America. He studied at Bucknell, Gordon-Conwell and Westminster and founded Redeemer Presbyterian Church in Manhattan in 1989. [en.wikipedia.org], [timothykeller.com]
Redeemer deliberately sought to create a church where skeptical, highly educated secular New Yorkers could ask serious questions about Christianity. It grew dramatically and created extensive church-planting and mercy-ministry networks. [timothykeller.com], [redeemer.com]
Keller remained relatively traditional on theological and sexual-ethics questions. What made him different from the Religious Right was his tone, urbanity, intellectual engagement, concern for mercy and justice, and reluctance to reduce Christianity to partisan politics.
His The Reason for God is basically:
"You are intelligent to have objections to Christianity. Let's actually examine them."
That's a very different approach from fundamentalism even when the final theological conclusions remain orthodox.
Think: intellectually sophisticated, culturally engaged Reformed evangelicalism.
9. Gabe Lyons
Gabe Lyons represents evangelical engagement with cultural institutions and public life.
He coauthored unChristian, which examined negative perceptions younger Americans held toward Christianity, and wrote The Next Christians. He founded Q Ideas, now developed as THINQ, to cultivate Christian thinking and dialogue about contemporary cultural questions. [gabelyons.com], [exponential.org]
His project is neither separatist fundamentalism nor progressive theological accommodation.
It is more:
Christians should understand the culture intelligently enough to contribute constructively to it while maintaining Christian convictions.
His current work remains explicitly concerned with applying Christian wisdom to contemporary cultural problems. [gabelyons.com]
Ideologically, Lyons is therefore notably more orthodox/conservative than McLaren or Bell.
Think: engage culture rather than retreat from it or assimilate into it.
10. Ecclesia Network
The Ecclesia Network is a network of missional churches, church planters and ministry leaders.
Its own current description is revealing: it calls itself a relational fellowship embracing the"historical, orthodox way of Jesus" while attempting to advance the gospel in a"post-church era." [ecclesianet.org]
That's almost a definition of the Neo-Evangelical territory you're mapping:
historical orthodoxy
+
recognition that Christendom is disappearing
+
experimentation with how church functions.
So Ecclesia isn't Emergent Village 2.0. Its identity is intentionally more anchored doctrinally.
Think: orthodox + missional + decentralized church network.
11. Fuller Theological Seminary
Fuller Theological Seminary may be the single most important institutional bridge in this entire discussion.
Fuller is evangelical, but represents an academically engaged form of evangelicalism. Today it incorporates a School of Mission and Theology alongside substantial psychology and marriage-and-family-therapy education and describes its formation as Christ-centered, Scriptural, Spirit-empowered, academically rigorous and intercultural. [fuller.edu], [fuller.edu]
That has historically created room for:
serious biblical scholarship,
psychology,
missions/missiology,
women in ministry,
engagement with culture,
racial and intercultural questions,
spiritual formation,
thoughtful interfaith conversation.
Its contemporary resources explicitly integrate questions of theology, psychology, mental health, race, technology, spiritual formation and interfaith dialogue. [fullerstud...fuller.edu]
So Fuller occupies roughly the territory between:
fundamentalism ← evangelical orthodoxy → academic/cultural openness.
It isn't Union Seminary. It isn't trying to become classic liberal Protestantism.
Given your own profession, Fuller's integration of theology and psychology may be particularly interesting to compare with The Seattle School. Both integrate psychological and theological disciplines, but Fuller remains much more recognizably within the broad evangelical tradition. [fuller.edu], [fuller.edu]
.png)

.png)

Comments
Post a Comment