Roots of Christian Nationalism

Christian Nationalism in the U.S. does have historical roots that map surprisingly well onto the regions described in American Nations by Colin Woodard.

 





American Nations: A History of the Eleven Rival Regional Cultures of North America - Kindle edition by Woodard, Colin. Politics & Social Sciences Kindle eBooks @ Amazon.com.

It isn’t from just one place — it’s a blend of several historical streams, but two regions are especially central:

  • Greater Appalachia

  • The Deep South

With some intellectual influence from Puritan New England and later political mobilization from the Sunbelt.

The Main Roots of Christian Nationalism


1. Puritan New England (The Original "Christian Nation" Idea)

nations and faith: Puritan

Region in American Nations: Yankeedom
Time Period: 1600s–1700s

Key figures:

  • John Winthrop

  • Cotton Mather

This is where the idea that America is chosen by God really begins.

"John Winthrop (January 12, 1587/88[1] – March 26, 1649) was an English Puritan lawyer and one of the leading figures in founding the Massachusetts Bay Colony, the second major settlement in New England following Plymouth Colony. Winthrop led the first large wave of colonists from England in 1630 and served as governor for 12 of the colony's first 20 years. His writings and vision of the colony as a Puritan "city upon a hill" dominated New England colonial development, influencing the governments and religions of neighboring colonies."


John Winthrop's famous phrase:

  • "A City Upon a Hill"

This belief included:

  • America has a divine mission

  • Government should reflect Christian values

  • Society should enforce moral behavior

However — this Puritan version eventually evolved into progressive reform movements:

  • Abolitionism

  • Temperance

  • Social reform

  • Public education

So New England provided the idea but not the modern political expression of Christian Nationalism.


Greater Appalachia | nations and faith

2. Greater Appalachia (The Cultural Core of Modern Christian Nationalism)

Region in American Nations: Greater Appalachia
Settlers: Scots-Irish borderlanders
Time period: 1700s onward

Key cultural features:

  • Fierce independence

  • Suspicion of elites

  • Honor culture

  • Warrior tradition

  • Evangelical Protestantism

Religious influence:

  • First Great Awakening

  • George Whitefield

This is where:

  • Emotional evangelical religion took hold

  • Personal salvation became central

  • Anti-establishment religion grew

This region later spreads west:

  • Tennessee

  • Kentucky

  • Texas

  • Oklahoma

  • Missouri

  • Southern Ohio (yes — including parts of where your Hunts Corner / Lyme Township ancestors were)

This is a major root of modern evangelical Christian political identity.


3. The Deep South (Hierarchy + Religion + Politics)

Region in American Nations: Deep South
Settlers: English slaveholding aristocrats

Key features:

  • Hierarchical worldview

  • Religion tied to authority

  • Social order emphasized

  • "God-ordained" leadership

Important development:
After the Civil War, churches became:

  • Cultural centers

  • Political organizing centers

  • Identity anchors

Later movements:

  • Southern Baptist Convention

  • Fundamentalism

These movements strongly shaped modern Christian Nationalism.


4. 20th Century Political Christian Nationalism

This is where modern Christian Nationalism really takes shape:

Key figures:

  • Billy Graham (soft political Christianity)

  • Jerry Falwell Sr.

  • Pat Robertson

  • James Dobson

Major movements:

  • Moral Majority

  • Christian Coalition

  • Focus on the Family

These grew largely in:

  • The South

  • Appalachia

  • Texas

  • Oklahoma

  • Arizona (Sunbelt expansion)






Comments

intro

Popular Posts