Christ to the American Settlers

 This is a fascinating question through the American Nations lens because the settlers were often not disagreeing about whether Jesus was important. They were disagreeing about what aspect of Jesus mattered most.

Yankeedom (Puritans and Congregationalists)

The Puritans of New England viewed Christ primarily as:

  • Savior from sin
  • Moral teacher
  • Lord over both individual and society

They believed a godly society should reflect biblical principles. Jesus was not only concerned with personal salvation but with creating a righteous community.

Their emphasis often fell on:

  • Covenant
  • Moral discipline
  • Education
  • Reforming society

This partly explains why New England later became a center of abolitionism, social reform, public education, and missionary movements.

Greater Pennsylvania (Quakers, Mennonites, Brethren)

This region may have focused most strongly on following the teachings of Jesus.

Quakers

Quakers emphasized:

  • The "Inner Light"
  • Direct experience of God
  • Peace
  • Equality

For them, Jesus was the model of divine love and truth rather than primarily a sacrifice satisfying God's wrath.

Mennonites and Brethren

Anabaptists often asked:

"What did Jesus tell us to do?"

Their focus was on:

  • Loving enemies
  • Refusing violence
  • Simplicity
  • Community
  • Discipleship

Many saw the Sermon on the Mount as the heart of Christian living.

Among all the colonies, these groups arguably put the strongest emphasis on imitating Jesus' lifestyle and teachings.



Tidewater (Anglican Virginia and Maryland elites)

Anglicans generally viewed Christ through the framework of:

  • Traditional creeds
  • Sacraments
  • Church order

Compared with Puritans, there was often less emphasis on conversion experiences and more emphasis on maintaining social and religious stability.

Christ was Savior and Lord, but religion was often intertwined with maintaining a hierarchical social order.


Deep South

The early plantation South was also largely Anglican, but religion tended to be weaker among elites than in New England.

Later, through evangelical revivals, many Southerners came to emphasize:

  • Personal conversion
  • Being "born again"
  • Jesus as personal Savior

This eventually became one of the defining features of Southern evangelicalism.

Greater Appalachia (Scots-Irish frontier)

The Scots-Irish settlers tended to emphasize:

  • Personal salvation
  • Individual responsibility
  • Emotional conversion experiences
  • Christ as a conquering, victorious Savior

Revival meetings often focused on:

  • Sin
  • Repentance
  • Redemption

Less energy was devoted to building a "Christian society" than among the Puritans. More energy was devoted to ensuring individuals experienced salvation.

New France (Quebec, Mississippi settlements)

French Catholics viewed Christ through:

  • Sacramental life
  • Church tradition
  • Saints
  • The Mass

Jesus was encountered through the Church and its rituals rather than primarily through individual Bible reading.

A Helpful Simplification

Different regions often centered different aspects of Jesus:

RegionPrimary Emphasis
YankeedomChrist the moral reformer and covenant Lord
Greater Pennsylvania (Quakers)Christ the teacher of peace and inner transformation
Greater Pennsylvania (Anabaptists)Christ the model disciple to be followed
TidewaterChrist the Lord of an ordered Christian society
Greater AppalachiaChrist the personal Savior
Deep South (later evangelical)Christ the personal Savior and redeemer
New FranceChrist present through the Church and sacraments

One of the enduring divisions in American religion is not whether people believe in Jesus, but which Jesus they emphasize. Some traditions primarily ask, "How can I be saved?" Others ask, "How should I live?" Others ask, "How do we build a godly society?" and still others, "How do we encounter God's presence?" All draw from the same Gospels, yet they often focus on different facets of the same Jewish teacher from Galilee. These differences shaped the cultures of the colonies and continue to influence the political, social, and religious character of the American Nations today.



"What did Jesus himself seem to teach as a Jewish teacher in first-century Judea?"

Jesus was born, lived, and died as a Jew. He attended synagogue, celebrated Jewish festivals, quoted the Hebrew Bible, and rarely spoke about creating a new religion. Instead, he described himself as fulfilling and deepening Israel's covenant with God.

1. Love God wholeheartedly

When asked about the greatest commandment, Jesus quoted the Jewish Shema (Deuteronomy 6:4-5):

Love the Lord your God with all your heart, soul, mind, and strength.

This was not a new teaching but the foundation of Jewish faith.

2. Love your neighbor

Jesus paired the Shema with Leviticus 19:18:

Love your neighbor as yourself.

He taught that all the law and prophets hang on these two commandments.

3. The Kingdom of God

More than any other topic, Jesus preached the "Kingdom of God."

By this he did not primarily mean heaven after death. He meant God's reign breaking into the world, transforming human relationships, justice, mercy, and faithfulness.

4. Inner transformation over outward performance

Jesus frequently challenged religious leaders who emphasized external compliance while neglecting:

  • mercy
  • justice
  • humility
  • compassion
  • sincerity

His criticism was often directed not at Judaism itself but at hypocrisy.

5. Care for the poor and marginalized

Jesus consistently focused on:

  • the poor
  • the sick
  • widows
  • children
  • foreigners
  • social outcasts

He taught that caring for vulnerable people was closely connected to serving God.

6. Forgiveness and reconciliation

Jesus emphasized forgiveness to an unusual degree:

  • forgive enemies
  • pray for persecutors
  • seek reconciliation
  • remove the "log" from your own eye before judging others

7. Radical nonviolence

This is one area where some scholars see Jesus as particularly distinctive:

  • turn the other cheek
  • love your enemies
  • bless those who curse you
  • put away the sword

Many Anabaptists later viewed these teachings as central rather than symbolic.

8. Humility over status

Jesus repeatedly reversed social expectations:

The first shall be last and the last shall be first.

Leadership, in his view, meant service rather than domination.

9. Faithfulness over legalism

Jesus generally did not reject Jewish law. Rather, he argued for its deeper purpose.

For example:

  • Anger violates the spirit of the prohibition against murder.
  • Lust violates the spirit of the prohibition against adultery.
  • Love of God and neighbor is the goal toward which the law points.

Why this matters for your American Nations interests

One of the most interesting divides among modern Christians is whether Jesus should be understood primarily as:

  • A savior whose death and resurrection provide salvation.
  • A teacher whose ethical and social teachings should shape daily life.
  • Both.

Historically, many Anabaptists emphasized following Jesus' teachings in everyday life, asking, "How should a disciple live?" Other Protestant traditions often focused more heavily on questions of grace, faith, salvation, and correct doctrine.

A historian trying to summarize Jesus' core message in the simplest terms might say:

God is bringing His kingdom into the world. Love God, love your neighbor, care for the vulnerable, forgive others, live humbly, and align your life with God's will.

Those themes would have sounded deeply Jewish to Jesus' original audience, even though Christianity later developed many beliefs and institutions beyond what Jesus explicitly taught during his lifetime.


PeriodMain OriginsApproximate Scale
1654-1820Sephardic Jews from Caribbean, Netherlands, EnglandThousands
1820-1880German-speaking Central EuropeHundreds of thousands
1880-1924Eastern Europe & Russian Empire2-2.5 million
1930-1950Nazi-era refugees & survivorsTens of thousands
1970-1990sSoviet UnionHundreds of thousands

This blog explores the history, culture, and beliefs that have shaped the American Nations. While I have a personal interest in religion and religious history, I am not affiliated with any religious organization, denomination, or faith tradition. My goal is to understand and discuss these topics from a historical, cultural, and sociological perspective rather than to promote any particular set of beliefs.  Jane Rekas, LCSW

Comments

intro

Popular Posts