Head coverings
The debate over women's head coverings reveals one of the most interesting tensions in American Christianity. Many conservative Protestant churches strongly affirm the inerrancy of Scripture, yet most no longer expect women to cover their heads in worship despite Paul's instructions in 1 Corinthians 11. Their reasoning is typically that the underlying principle is timeless, while the head covering itself was a cultural expression of that principle. Conservative Anabaptists, by contrast, have tended to see the covering as a continuing practice because Paul grounds his argument not in local custom, but in creation, worship, and the practices of the early church.
From an American Nations perspective, this difference reflects deeper cultural instincts. The descendants of the radical Protestant movements that settled parts of Greater Pennsylvania, including Mennonites, Amish, Brethren, and other Anabaptist groups, often emphasized discipleship expressed through visible practices. Faith was not merely something one believed, but something one lived. A plain coat, a prayer covering, or refusal to swear oaths served as tangible evidence of a commitment to follow Christ. By contrast, much of the Evangelical tradition that developed in Greater Appalachia and the Deep South increasingly focused on doctrinal orthodoxy, personal conversion, and biblical authority while becoming less attached to historic forms of dress and worship.
The question is not whether communities that retain head coverings are more devout or more controlling. The answer can be either. Visible religious practices can foster humility, shared identity, and resistance to consumer culture. They can also become tools of conformity and social pressure. A healthier question is whether a community encourages sincere discipleship while allowing room for conscience, questions, and spiritual growth.
Perhaps the most surprising historical fact is that the Amish and conservative Mennonites are not preserving an obscure practice. For most of Christian history, Catholic, Orthodox, Protestant, and Anabaptist women commonly covered their heads in church. The real historical question is not why some groups still do it, but why so many others stopped. That question invites Christians not merely to defend their traditions, but to examine how culture, theology, and history shape what they consider essential to faithful living.
Groups that generally practice women's head coverings
| Denomination/Group | Practice |
|---|---|
| Old Order Amish | Women wear a prayer covering (kapp) virtually all the time, with style varying by affiliation. |
| Old Order Mennonites | Women wear coverings daily; size and style vary among groups. |
| Conservative Mennonites | Many expect women to wear coverings, though practices vary from daily wear to church-only wear. |
| Beachy Amish Mennonites | Most churches expect coverings, often a mesh, lace, or fabric covering. |
| Charity Churches | Generally maintain the practice of women's coverings. |
| Apostolic Christian Church (Nazarene branch and some related groups) | Women commonly wear coverings in worship and often at all times. |
| German Baptist Brethren / Old German Baptist Brethren | Continue the practice among women. |
| Dunkard Brethren | Women wear head coverings, typically as a sign of biblical obedience. |
Groups where it is less common or optional
| Denomination | Typical Practice |
|---|---|
| Mainline Mennonite Church USA | Usually does not require head coverings; some individual members may choose to wear them. |
| Mennonite Brethren | Generally do not practice head coverings today. |
| Brethren in Christ (modern) | Historically practiced them, but most congregations no longer do. |
"Every man who prays or prophesies with his head covered dishonors his head. But every woman who prays or prophesies with her head uncovered dishonors her head..."
(1 Corinthians 11:4-5)"For this reason a woman ought to have authority over her head, because of the angels."
(1 Corinthians 11:10)"Judge for yourselves: Is it proper for a woman to pray to God with her head uncovered?"
(1 Corinthians 11:13)
Christians interpret it several ways:
Literal and timeless command
Some churches (certain Mennonite, Amish, Brethren, conservative Anabaptist, Eastern Orthodox, and some Holiness groups) believe women should still wear a head covering during worship or at all times.Cultural practice in Corinth
Many scholars argue Paul was addressing first-century Corinthian customs regarding modesty, respectability, and marital status, rather than establishing a universal rule for all Christians.Hair as the covering
Some interpret verses 14-15 to mean that a woman's long hair itself is the covering Paul intended:"Her hair is given to her for a covering."
(1 Corinthians 11:15)
Canon Law
The 1917 Code of Canon Law explicitly required women to have covered heads in church:
Women, however, shall have a covered head and be modestly dressed, especially when they approach the table of the Lord.
What Changed?
Following Vatican II (1962-1965), many Catholics assumed the requirement had been relaxed. Then, when the 1983 Code of Canon Law replaced the 1917 code, the head-covering requirement was omitted entirely.
As a result:
- Women are no longer required by Catholic law to wear a veil or head covering at Mass.
- Most Catholic women today do not cover their heads.
- The Church does not consider veiling necessary for receiving Communion or attending Mass.
Who Still Veils?
You'll still frequently find veils among:
- Traditional Latin Mass communities
- Some conservative Catholics
- Certain converts who appreciate historical Catholic practices
- Some women who view it as a personal devotion or sign of reverence
For them, veiling is typically understood as:
- Reverence before God
- Humility
- A reminder of sacred space
- Continuity with Catholic tradition
Difference from Conservative Anabaptists
The biggest distinction is that conservative Anabaptists generally see head covering as an ongoing biblical command, while Catholics today usually see veiling as a respected tradition and personal devotion rather than a universal obligation.
Many Traditions. One Right: The Freedom to Choose.
I've seen an awful lot of memes circulating lately, along with an equally disturbing amount of Islamophobia. And somewhere in the middle of all of it, I started thinking about something.
How many different types of head coverings are there, anyway?
I've worked with people from all over the world, from different religions, cultures, and backgrounds. Over the years, I've seen women wear an incredible variety of scarves, veils, wraps, bonnets, turbans, and other head coverings.
Some look remarkably similar but have completely different names. Others look different but serve similar purposes. And sometimes the same type of covering has different meanings depending on the culture, religion, or individual wearing it.
So, naturally, I got curious.
And because apparently I don't have enough to do, I started digging.
What I discovered was fascinating.
Islam certainly doesn't have a monopoly on head coverings. Neither does Christianity, Judaism, or any other religion.
Muslim women may wear hijabs, shaylas, khimars, chadors, niqabs, or other styles. Some wear loosely draped scarves that leave part of their hair visible. Others don't cover their hair at all.
Jewish women, particularly in some Orthodox communities, may wear tichels, snoods, hats, turbans, or even wigs called sheitels.
Catholic women have worn mantillas and chapel veils for centuries. Catholic and Eastern Orthodox nuns wear religious veils. Some Orthodox Christian women cover their hair during worship, and similar traditions exist in other Christian communities.
Amish, Mennonite, and Hutterite women have their own distinctive prayer coverings.
Sikh women may wear turbans or scarves. Hindu women may drape a sari pallu or dupatta over their heads. And there are additional examples in Jain, Cao Dai, Druze, Zoroastrian, and other religious and cultural communities.
Then there are the beautiful head wraps found throughout African cultures, Rastafari traditions, and countless other communities around the world.
And here's what I found particularly interesting: Judaism, Christianity, and Islam all have long histories of women covering their hair for religious reasons.
Three religions with different teachings, yet some remarkably similar traditions.
Of course, the reasons women wear these coverings vary tremendously. For some, it's faith. For others, modesty, cultural identity, family tradition, fashion, or simply personal preference.
And sometimes, unfortunately, it isn't a choice.
That brings me to the burqa, also called the chadari in Afghanistan. Unlike a simple headscarf, it's a full-body covering. Under Taliban rule, women face severe restrictions on their clothing and freedom of movement. Other women, in different circumstances, may choose to wear similar coverings voluntarily.
Those are very different situations, and we should be able to recognize that distinction.
Forcing a woman to cover herself is wrong. Forcing a woman to uncover herself against her will is also wrong.
That's the entire point.
Living in a country that protects religious freedom means recognizing that other people have the right to make choices we might not make ourselves.
You don't have to understand someone's religion, agree with their beliefs, or adopt their traditions to respect their rights.
And seeing a woman wearing a hijab doesn't tell you whether she's oppressed, liberated, conservative, progressive, educated, uneducated, happy, unhappy, or anything else about her life.
It tells you she's wearing a hijab.
That's it.
I put together this broader infographic based on what I found. I included women's head coverings that I saw in others had been missed.
It's meant to be educational, not an exhaustive academic reference. There are undoubtedly additional traditions and regional variations I haven't included, and some terminology differs between communities. If I've missed something or mislabeled a particular style, I'm always happy to learn.
Because that's what curiosity is supposed to do. Help us learn about one another instead of making assumptions.
And considering how much misinformation I've seen circulating lately, I think we could all benefit from a little more curiosity and a lot less judgment.
The principle is simple: Every woman deserves the right to cover or uncover her hair and face without coercion or punishment.
Not just women who share your religion.
Not just women whose choices you understand.
Every woman.
Different faiths. Different cultures. Different traditions. Equal dignity and freedom of choice.
This blog explores the history, culture, and beliefs that have shaped the American Nations. While I have a personal interest in religion and religious history, I am not affiliated with any religious organization, denomination, or faith tradition. My goal is to understand and discuss these topics from a historical, cultural, and sociological perspective rather than to promote any particular set of beliefs. Jane Rekas, LCSW




Comments
Post a Comment